Dad’s Vanilla Ice Cream

Every family has one dessert that lives or dies in the freezer. Ours is vanilla ice cream — the kind Sam has been making since before I could reach the counter. For as long as I can remember, there’s been a tub of it waiting in our freezer, and I’m pretty sure almost everyone who’s ever sat at our table has ended up with a scoop of it, even the ones who swore they were just trying a little.

It’s unapologetically old-school: whole milk, eggs, plenty of sugar, and an entire pint of heavy cream. No shortcuts, no cottage cheese sneaking in. It churns up exactly like the hand-crank version we used to make in the garage as kids — rich, smooth, and full of that classic vanilla flavor. It’s still one of my favorite things to make, and every bite tastes like nostalgia. So dust off the ice cream maker and let’s make a batch.

How to Make Dad’s Vanilla Ice Cream

Ingredients

• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 2 large eggs
• ½ teaspoon fine sea salt
• 2 cups whole milk
• 1 pint heavy whipping cream
• 2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract

Equipment: an ice cream maker (no-maker options in the FAQ below).

Instructions

1. Whisk the base. In a medium bowl, whisk the sugar, eggs, and fine sea salt together until smooth and slightly pale.
2. Warm the milk. In a medium saucepan, heat the whole milk over medium heat until steaming but not boiling.
3. Temper the eggs. While whisking constantly, slowly drizzle about 1 cup of the hot milk into the egg mixture. Then pour the tempered eggs back into the saucepan with the remaining milk, whisking constantly.
4. Cook the custard. Keep cooking over medium-low heat, stirring often, until it thickens slightly and coats the back of a spoon, about 5 to 8 minutes. Do not let it boil.
5. Add the cream and vanilla. Remove from the heat and stir in the heavy whipping cream and vanilla extract.
6. Chill. Strain the mixture through a fine-mesh strainer into a clean bowl or container. Cover and refrigerate until completely cold — at least 4 hours, or overnight.
7. Churn. Churn in your ice cream maker until thick and creamy, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
8. Freeze. Transfer to a freezer-safe container, cover, and freeze for at least 2 to 4 hours, or until firm enough to scoop. Serve and enjoy.

The Details That Make or Break It

Homemade ice cream is pretty forgiving, but a few little habits keep this custard especially smooth. These are the ones I learned the slow way.

• Don’t rush the tempering. Drizzling the hot milk into the eggs slowly, while whisking, is what keeps you from ending up with sweet scrambled eggs. Go slower than you think you need to.
• Keep the heat gentle. Never let the custard boil — medium-low is your friend. If it boils, the eggs curdle and there’s no coming back from that.
• Use the spoon test. The custard is done when it coats the back of a spoon and you can drag a clean line through it with your finger. It will still look fairly thin, and that’s okay.
• Always strain. Even if you did everything right, straining through a fine mesh strainer catches any little cooked egg bits and guarantees a silky base.
• Chill the base completely before churning. Overnight is ideal. A lukewarm base churns up icy and takes forever — patience pays.
• Freeze the maker bowl ahead of time. If your machine uses a freezer bowl, it needs to be in the freezer at least 24 hours. A half-frozen bowl is the number one reason homemade ice cream turns out soupy.
• Use good vanilla. With so few ingredients, the vanilla really shines — use pure vanilla extract, not the imitation stuff.

Ways to Make It Your Own

This custard base is a blank canvas, so have some fun with it:

• Vanilla bean: scrape the seeds of one vanilla bean into the milk as it warms, for flecked, extra-fragrant ice cream.
• Chocolate: add chopped chocolate or mini chocolate chips during the last few minutes of churning.
• Caramel or fudge swirl: layer ribbons of salted caramel or hot fudge into the container as you transfer the churned ice cream to the freezer.
• Boozy: stir 1 to 2 tablespoons of bourbon or rum into the chilled base before churning. Bonus — the alcohol keeps the ice cream softer and more scoopable.
• Crunch: fold in crushed cookies, toasted pecans, or waffle cone pieces at the end of churning.
• Brown sugar: swap in half brown sugar for a subtle caramel-y depth.
• Berries: toss chopped fresh strawberries or raspberries with a spoonful of sugar, let them sit for 15 minutes, then fold them in at the very end of churning.

FAQ

Can I make this without an ice cream maker? An ice cream maker gives you the creamiest results, but you can pour the chilled base into a shallow pan, freeze it, and stir vigorously with a fork every 30 minutes for about 3 hours. The texture will be a little icier, but still delicious.

Can I make the base ahead of time? Absolutely — in fact, I think it works best that way. Prepare the custard, cover it, and refrigerate it overnight. Churn it the next day once it’s completely cold.

Why is my ice cream so hard after freezing? Homemade ice cream doesn’t contain the stabilizers that store-bought varieties do, so it freezes more firmly. Just let the container sit on the counter for 5 to 10 minutes before scooping.

Can I double the recipe? Yes, as long as your ice cream maker is large enough. Otherwise, churn in two batches and keep the second half of the base chilled in the fridge while the first one churns.

A Note From Nora

My first batch of this came out more like vanilla slush than ice cream, and I blamed the vanilla. It was the bowl — I’d only given it 12 hours in the freezer instead of 24, and it never stood a chance. Sam didn’t even comment. He just finished the slush and refilled his bowl. This one passes the Tuesday test with room to spare, if you plan ahead the day before: the base chills overnight, and the churning takes less time than the pasta does on an actual Tuesday. If I can make it on a Tuesday, it’s a keeper.

Keep Reading

• Ritz Carlton Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
• Chewy Browned Butter Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies
• The Screwdriver: My Foolproof Two-Ingredient Cocktail